Why Immigration Does Not Reduce World Poverty
(a short explanation)
By Roy Beck, journalist and founder of NumbersUSA
In this brief presentation, backed by statistics and visuals, Roy Beck explains why immigration is both an ineffective and pointless solution, and why it would be far more appropriate to help underdeveloped populations in their own countries rather than bringing a tiny minority to our shores.
Roy Beck presents his analysis, arguing that not only those we welcome represent a drop in the ocean of global poverty, but they are among the least disadvantaged, since they had the physical and intellectual means to make their way to us.
He defends the view that the selective immigration we practice is pointless since it does nothing to solve global poverty and, moreover, deprives those populations of their most energetic members.
Who is Roy Beck?
Roy Beck is an American journalist and policy advocate, best known as the founder and president of NumbersUSA, an organization established in 1996 that focuses on immigration policy in the United States.He began his career as a reporter, notably for the Grand Rapids Press, before specializing in the analysis of immigration policies and their economic, social, and environmental impacts. Through NumbersUSA, Roy Beck promotes policies aimed at reducing both legal and illegal immigration, emphasizing their effects on the labor market, population growth, and resource use. He is also known for his educational presentations, including videos and public talks, in which he uses visual demonstrations to explain complex issues related to global migration.
The demonstration presented in this video is based on precise figures and a fast sequence of arguments. To better follow the reasoning and review the numbers at your own pace, you can read the full transcript below.
▶ Read full video transcript
Video transcript
Some people say that mass immigration into the United States can help reduce world poverty. Is that true? Well, no it's not. And let me show you why.
This gumball represents the one million legal immigrants that the United States has taken every year on average since 1990. Who in the world deserves our humanitarian compassion? The World Bank has one measure of the desperately poor of the world. They make less than $2 a day.
And how many people make less than $2 a day in the world? Let's start with Africa. In Africa alone, there are 650 million people who make less than $2 a day.
In India, another 890 million people are desperately poor. China adds another 480 million people making less than $2 a day.
And the rest of Asia has 810 million people in the same situation. Finally, Latin America has 105 million people living in extreme poverty.
In total, the World Bank estimates that there are around 3 billion people living on less than $2 a day.
That represents 3,000 gumballs. And every year, we take one million and suggest that this somehow represents a meaningful humanitarian impact.
We do not take immigrants from the poorest populations. These individuals are often too poor or too disconnected to migrate.
Most immigrants come from relatively better-off developing countries. Mexico, for example, plays a major role in shaping immigration flows.
Mexico itself is a relatively poor country. And there are 5.6 billion people in the world living in countries with average incomes lower than Mexico.
So what are policymakers telling us? That taking one million immigrants somehow addresses global poverty.
Even if immigration were doubled, the impact on global poverty would remain negligible.
Immigrants are often among the most energetic and capable individuals in their home countries.
Meanwhile, the real drivers of change are those who remain and work to improve conditions locally.
Each year, tens of millions are added to impoverished populations through natural growth, far exceeding migration flows.
Immigration cannot meaningfully address global poverty at scale.
The only realistic solution is to improve conditions where people live.
99.9% of people in extreme poverty will never migrate to a wealthy country.
They must be helped where they are.
Let’s help them there.
- Explore More Articles in English -
- The Diamond Market
- Investing in Gold and Silver
- Cryptocurrencies : Understanding Digital Assets, Opportunities and Risks
- Will the Internet One Day Consume All Global Electricity Production?
- Do you have to erase your visual cryptogram?
- Why do they leave France?
- Why Immigration Does Not Reduce World Poverty
If you understand French, you can also explore many additional financial articles available on the French version of La Page Financière .